Shelly Belly NY Bagels
Bagel Shop, Pahrump
Seat #312 is saved for this business.
Shelly Belly NY Bagels is a family-owned Pahrump bagel, coffee and sandwich shop on East Nevada Highway 372 that also offers catering and online ordering.
Shelly Belly NY Bagels is a bagel and coffee shop at 1190 East Nevada Highway 372, Suite 1, in Pahrump. Its website describes it as family-owned and -operated and says it serves bagels, spreads, coffee, sandwiches and other baked goods. The Better Business Bureau lists Shelley Fisher as owner and manager and gives May 3, 2021 as the business start date.
Eating in and ordering
The site offers a menu, online ordering with pickup or delivery options, and a reservation link for a table at breakfast or brunch. It does not post opening hours, so call before you go. The Visit Pahrump tourism listing gives the same address and phone number.
Catering is part of the offering. The website says party trays and package deals are available for groups from one person up to 100, which suits office breakfasts, family gatherings and similar events.
In the community
The Pahrump Valley Times reported on a campaign meet-and-greet for a sheriff candidate held at the shop, calling it a local bakery. The article names Fisher as the shop’s owner and quotes her saying the candidate is approachable. The candidate thanked her for hosting.
What we could not confirm
The shop’s ordering site is hosted on a Shift4 online-shop platform address. Visit Pahrump lists a different web address for the shop, which could not be opened during this check, so the website link below is the one the business uses for online ordering. The BBB rates the business A+ but it is not BBB accredited.
Contact Shelly Belly NY Bagels
1190 East Nevada Highway 372, Suite 1, Pahrump
775-469-9064
Business website
Researched October 20, 2026 from the business’s own website and independent evidence. Source 1 · Source 2 · Source 3 · Source 4. Independent researched listing; not an owner interview. For corrections or removal, email cody@702alliance.com.
Is this your business?
Seat 312 is saved for you. Claim it free: reply “yes” to Cody's email, call (725) 202-7691, or text Cody at (725) 502-3114. Something wrong, or rather not be listed? Email cody@702alliance.com and it's fixed or taken down.